Grill reviews · Every product bought at retail price · No sponsored scores
🔥 Grills & Backyard Gear, Tested Over Fire
Cook outside. Buy the right fire.
Charcoal, gas, pellet, and the tools around them — bought at retail price, cooked on through a full season, and scored on heat control, cleanup, and whether they survive weather.
Choose your fire first, then the tools that keep it working. Every grill here was cooked on through a full season, not a single afternoon.
LANE 01
CHARCOAL
480–700°F Slow start, best flavor
Light it, wait for the gray ash, and cook with two zones. The cheapest way to real smoke.
9.1/10
CHARCOAL
KettleKing Charcoal Grill
A 22-inch kettle with a hinged grate and a lid holder that keeps the lid off the ground. Two-zone setup works without adding a charcoal basket.
22-INCHTWO-ZONE
8.8/10
CHARCOAL
SlowSmoke Offset Smoker
A well-sealed offset smoker that holds 225°F for six hours with a small fire. The stack is tall enough to draw properly, which cheap offsets get wrong.
OFFSETHOLDS 225°F
8.7/10
CHARCOAL
ChimneySure Starter
A chimney starter that lights coals in twelve minutes with two sheets of newspaper. The heat shield keeps the handle usable without a glove.
12-MIN LIGHTHEAT SHIELD
LANE 02
GAS
350–700°F Fast, controllable
Preheat in ten minutes and dial the burners. Buy for even heat across the grates, not the lid thermometer.
9.0/10
GAS
TwinBurn Gas Grill
A two-burner gas grill with cast-iron grates that reaches 550°F over the whole surface, not just the middle. The side shelves fold down for a small patio.
2 BURNERSCAST IRON
8.6/10
GAS
SearZone Infrared Grill
An infrared sear burner that puts a steakhouse crust on a steak in ninety seconds. It is a one-trick grill, and the trick is very good.
INFRARED900°F SEAR
8.9/10
GAS
GriddlePro Flat Top
A flat-top griddle that heats evenly enough for pancakes and smash burgers on the same surface. The grease trap actually empties without a fight.
FLAT TOPEVEN HEAT
LANE 03
PELLET
180–500°F Set and forget
Feed the hopper, set the temperature, and walk away. The lane for long cooks and cold-weather reliability.
9.2/10
PELLET
PelletPilot Pellet Grill
A pellet grill that holds temperature within 15°F through a windy afternoon and starts reliably in the cold. It smokes and grills without babysitting.
±15°FAUTO FEED
8.5/10
PELLET
SmokeTube Pellet Tube
A perforated tube that adds an hour of smoke to any gas or charcoal grill. Cheap, simple, and better than most smoke boxes.
1 HR SMOKEFITS ANY GRILL
8.9/10
PELLET
WirelessMeat Thermometer
A two-probe thermometer with a receiver that reaches the kitchen and an alarm you can hear. The probes survive being left in the grill.
2 PROBES300 FT RANGE
LANE 04
PATIO
Radiant The gear around the fire
Covers, tools, and heat. These are the pieces that decide whether the grill is still usable in April.
8.6/10
PATIO
ArmorGrill Cover
A fitted cover with sealed seams that does not pool water on top or flap in wind. It survives a full winter without cracking.
SEALED SEAMSWINTER-PROOF
8.7/10
PATIO
TongsAndTurner Set
Long-handled tongs with a real spring and a wide turner that gets under a burger without bending. Both hang on the same hook.
LONG HANDLESTAINLESS
8.4/10
PATIO
PatioHeat Tower
A patio heater that throws usable heat six feet out and lights on the first click. The base is heavy enough to stay upright in a gust.
6-FT THROWWIND-STABLE
🚫
What We Skip
Five shortcuts that cost more than they save, learned on our own patio.
✕
Skip lighter fluid. A chimney starter lights faster, tastes cleaner, and does not leave a chemical note on the food.
✕
Skip any grill that advertises a lid temperature as a cooking temperature. The grates are what matter.
✕
Skip covers made of thin plastic with taped seams. They trap condensation and crack in the first hard freeze.
✕
Skip a 6-burner grill for a two-person patio. You will heat half of it and clean all of it.
✕
Skip built-in thermometers as your only read. A $25 probe thermometer is more accurate than any lid gauge.
Making the Season Last
The maintenance schedule that keeps a grill working for ten years instead of three.
AFTER EVERY COOK
Brush the grates while hot, empty the ash cold, and cover if rain is coming.
MONTHLY
Check burner tubes for spider webs and grease. A blocked tube is the usual cause of uneven heat.
BEFORE WINTER
Deep-clean the firebox, oil cast iron, and store propane indoors — never in a hot garage.
EACH SPRING
Replace worn gaskets and test the thermometer in boiling water. Re-season the grates.
How we score grills and gear. Each score weighs heat control, build quality, cleanup, and how the unit holds up through a full season of weather. Fire is dangerous: read the manual, keep an extinguisher nearby, and never grill indoors or under a low roof. We are not a retailer and do not sell any product.
Our Method
How We Test
A simple, repeatable process — the same for every product we review.
01
We Buy It Ourselves
Every product is purchased at retail price. Brands don’t get a say or a preview of our results.
02
We Live With It
Real homes, real routines — we install, we leak-test, we wear it, we break it. If it can’t survive real use, it doesn’t score well.
03
We Give One Verdict
One clear score out of 10, with the honest trade-offs shown. No vague “best-in-class” fluff.
04
We Re-Test Yearly
Re-reviewed every year. When something better comes along, we update the score — even if it means demoting a favorite.
🧾
How this site earns money
We earn through affiliate commissions and display ads — at no cost to you. Commissions never influence our verdicts, and we never accept payment for a good score. See our Disclosure.
